Why Potty Training Your Puppy Is Not Working

You’re taking your puppy out to pee all the time but they’re still having accidents in the house All. The. Time! What gives?

Potty training is not quite as simple as taking your puppy out all the time. If your puppy has the opportunity to pee in the house as well, they’re going to.

If you’re struggling with your puppy’s potty training, the most likely culprit is that you’re giving your puppy way too much freedom. If you want your potty training to be successful, follow these simple steps instead…


Supervise your puppy when they’re loose

When your puppy has free time in your house, they must be supervised. This does not mean you’re scrolling through social media while your puppy wanders off and pees on the floor. Supervised means that your eyes are on your puppy, watching for any signs that they may need to potty. Signs like…

  • Suddenly stopping in the middle of play to sniff the floor

  • Suddenly wandering off away from you

  • Wandering near the door

Some puppies will become extra bitey, or their play will become frantic when they need to potty. Remember that the younger your puppy is, the less of a brain/bladder connection they have, so no, they really can’t wait while you put your shoes on. They need to go right now.

Confine your puppy when you can’t supervise

In the early stages of potty training, even if you’re just going to wash the dishes or make yourself a sandwich, if your eyes aren’t on your puppy, they need to be confined where they aren’t going to potty. Confinement can be:

  • A crate

  • A playpen or x-pen

  • Tethered to you or tethered close to you

Immediately before their confinement, make sure they’ve gone out to potty and take them out again when you release them from confinement, even if it’s only been 10 minutes.

Take your puppy to their potty area often

If your puppy is under 4 months old, you’ll want to take them out about every hour when they’re awake. If they’re sleeping, you can let them rest, but make sure you take them out as soon as they wake up.

Some other times to take your puppy out are:

  • Whenever they transition from one activity to another (they were playing and now they’re going to take a nap)

  • Whenever they suddenly start sniffing around on the floor

  • Whenever they suddenly wander away from you

  • About 15 minutes after they’ve had a drink of water

  • About 30 minutes after they’ve had a meal

  • Whenever they wake up from sleeping, even if they’ve only been sleeping for a short time

  • Whenever they wander near the door, even if they were just out (this will help them learn to go to the door when they need to go out)

More tips & tricks

If you are consistent and never give your puppy the opportunity to potty in the house during their first 3 months with you, you’ll have a well-trained pup. If you’re not consistent, then potty training could drag on indefinitely. As you work through potty training your puppy, keep these things in mind:

  • If your puppy potties in the house, this is YOUR mistake, not your puppy’s. It means you were not supervising your puppy closely enough.

  • If your puppy still manages to potty in the house even under strict supervision or seems to need to potty far more frequently than you feel is reasonable, have the vet check them over to rule out any physical/health issues.

  • Avoid scolding your puppy if they potty in the house. Scolding them can make them anxious about going potty in front of you, which will cause them to avoid going while they’re on a leash outside and sneak off to go inside.

  • Try to develop an eat/sleep/potty schedule for the first few months so that you know when your puppy will need to potty.

Walks, Playtime, and Fun

One of the mistakes many people make is taking their puppy for a walk to get them to pee, and the walk is over as soon as the puppy goes. One reason this can be a problem is that the outdoors is exciting, so your puppy is distracted by the world around it and not paying attention to their bladder. Another reason is that your puppy learns that the faster they potty, the quicker the fun ends.

Instead, when you take your puppy out to potty, limit how much space you let them wander in and be super boring. Once they’ve peed, take them for a walk or engage them in play. Your puppy will learn that the faster they potty, the quicker the fun starts.

Previous
Previous

The Illusion of Tools That “Work”

Next
Next

Puppy Training Made Easy